Navigating Political Gaslighting: Staying Grounded in a Divisive Climate
top of page

Navigating Political Gaslighting: Staying Grounded in a Divisive Climate

  • Writer: Jodi Hardesty
    Jodi Hardesty
  • Jul 21
  • 3 min read
In today's highly charged political landscape, many of us are experiencing political gaslighting, which distorts reality and creates deep divisions. As a mental health therapist, coach, and course creator, I've been deeply concerned by the "us vs. them" mentalities and the emotional reactivity this fosters. Understanding how gaslighting works and learning strategies to stay grounded is crucial.

You can keep reading this article or go to my homepage for the video version.


Understanding Political Gaslighting

Political gaslighting is often employed to elicit an emotional reaction and manipulate perceptions. It's important to recognize that neither side of the political spectrum is entirely immune to using these tactics. If you find yourself feeling intensely reactive during political discussions, it might be a sign that underlying manipulation is at play.

Signs You Are Being Gaslit

Here are some key indicators that you might be experiencing political gaslighting:
  • Invalidation of Experience: You are told that your personal experiences or feelings don't matter or are not valid.

  • Personal Attacks: Conversations quickly devolve into insults, name-calling, or character attacks, rather than addressing the substance of your points.

  • Pressure to Conform: You feel pressured to agree quickly, with the implication that disagreement makes you complicit in something negative.

  • Shame for Curiosity: You are made to feel ashamed for asking questions, expressing doubts, or showing curiosity, especially if it opposes a political party's agenda. This is particularly concerning as few issues are truly black and white; most are nuanced and complex.

  • Media Discrediting: Your preferred media sources are dismissed as inaccurate. while their sources are presented as infallible and beyond question. When different sources present completely different realities, it suggests a distortion of truth, potentially on both sides.

  • Denial and Word Twisting: Facts are denied outright, or your words are twisted to make you seem extreme or unreasonable.

  • Confusion and Self-Doubt: After conversations, you feel confused, anxious, or unsure, leading you to doubt your own grasp on reality. This can make it incredibly difficult to discern what is real.

It's vital to recognize that emotional triggers often serve someone else's agenda. Taking a deep breath and acknowledging your feelings can help prevent you from feeding into fear-baiting rhetoric.

Strategies to Stay Grounded

In this volatile environment, staying grounded requires conscious effort:
  • Fact-Check Across the Spectrum: Actively seek information from reputable sources across the entire political spectrum. This can be frustrating as you'll encounter views that challenge your comfort zone, but it's essential to move beyond an "our team vs. their team" mentality.

  • Avoid Echo Chambers: If everyone you interact with shares your exact political philosophy, you're likely in an echo chamber, leading to a skewed perspective. Seek out and engage with people who hold different views to broaden your understanding.

  • Embrace Curiosity Over Defensiveness: Instead of debating, ask questions to understand. Phrases like, "Help me understand what you mean by that," or "Can you clarify why that evokes such a strong reaction for you?" can foster genuine dialogue rather than confrontation.

  • Trust Your Gut While Remaining Open: Trust your personal experiences and values. If something feels "off," it probably is. However, also be aware that information can be designed to trigger fear, making you feel off-kilter and susceptible to manipulation. Remember, intuition relies is often presented as a calm sense of knowing, not fear.

  • Don't Let Shame Silence You: Don't be afraid to engage in respectful conversations, even on sensitive topics. You can ask for clarification without being defensive or argumentative.

  • Seek Trusted Perspectives: Connect with friends or mentors who value nuance and can help you "reality-test" information and your perceptions. This prevents isolation and provides a balanced viewpoint.


Final Thoughts

Remember, political gaslighting isn't about genuine disagreement; it's about manipulation. Its goal is to make you doubt yourself, your morals, and your grip on reality. This tactic is not limited to one side of the political divide.
The most effective antidote is to remain grounded through self-awareness, emotional regulation, and respectful dialogue. While challenging, having respectful conversations is possible and essential for navigating our current political climate. Keep in mind that very few truths are completely black and white.

bottom of page